You try an antidepressant for six weeks and feel nothing. A cholesterol pill leaves your legs aching. Your doctor switches you to another, and then another. A new study suggests some of that trial and error may be written in your DNA.
Published on November 11 in Science Translational Medicine, the University of Pittsburgh-led study found that nearly one in four people had been prescribed a medication their genes might call into question. It is a striking number, but it describes how often a mismatch shows up on paper, not how many people were actually harmed, and that difference shapes what you should do with it.
Key takeaways
Researchers looked at 16 genes in 98,590 people from the U.S. All of Us Research Program.
Every participant carried at least one variant that can affect how medications work.
About 24.4 percent had been prescribed a drug that guidelines suggest could need a different choice or dose for their genes.
The study did not measure whether anyone had side effects or poorer results because of it.
Pharmacogenetic tests are not covered by public health plans in Canada, so ask before you pay for one.
What did the study actually find?
The team combined whole-genome sequencing with electronic health records for 98,590 participants, focusing on 16 genes with well-established links to how people respond to drugs. Every single participant carried at least one relevant variant. When the researchers matched genes to prescriptions, the study found 24.4 percent had been prescribed at least one medication known to interact with a variant they carried.
The drugs that came up most often included ondansetron for nausea, ibuprofen, and the acid reflux drugs omeprazole and pantoprazole, according to the university. More than 300 medications now carry label information about gene and drug interactions where testing may guide prescribing.
The limit matters as much as the headline. The study counted how often a prescription and a gene did not line up, and it did not check whether those people had more side effects or got less benefit. Writing about the work, the senior author, Dr. Philip Empey, noted that genes are only one factor, alongside age, kidney and liver function, and other medications.

How do genes change the way a medication works?
The idea behind pharmacogenetic testing is simple. Some of the genes you inherit control the enzymes that break down certain drugs, so the same dose can build up in one person and clear too quickly in another. That can mean side effects at a normal dose, or a drug that seems to do nothing.
For a few medications, the stakes are higher. Testing can flag people who are unlikely to respond to clopidogrel (Plavix), a blood thinner used after a heart stent, so a doctor can choose another option. If you have ever had a reaction that seemed out of proportion, our guide to the medication side effects no one warns you about explains what else can be going on.
Is genetic testing used in Canada?
It is used in Canada, but mostly in specialized settings. Dr. James Kennedy, head of the Tanenbaum Centre for Pharmacogenetics at Toronto's Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH), has used it with more than 11,000 patients, many of whom had already tried several antidepressants. A CAMH-led trial of 276 people with hard-to-treat depression found that test-guided prescribing was linked to higher remission rates, though the trial was small.
Cost is the real catch for most families. Kennedy has pointed out that these tests are not covered by public health plans in Canada, so most people pay privately or through workplace benefits. That raises a fair question about who gets access, since the people who could benefit most are not always the ones who can afford it. Questions like this land between federal and provincial decisions, as our guide to who decides what in Canadian health care explains.
What should you ask your pharmacist or doctor?
Genetic testing makes the most sense if you have struggled through several drugs for the same condition. When you ask your pharmacist or doctor, a few questions help, and our guide to what your pharmacist wishes you knew covers what else to bring up.
Ask whether testing fits your situation. It is most useful after two or three failed medications, or side effects at a normal dose.
Ask about cost and coverage. Check whether your workplace benefits cover it, since public plans do not.
Share any results you already have. Bring reports from a private company or research program to your pharmacist and doctor.
Keep a current medication list. Our free medication list template makes it easy to keep track of everything you take.
Do not change anything on your own. A test result is one piece of information your prescriber weighs with everything else about you.
Frequently asked questions
What is pharmacogenetic testing?
Pharmacogenetic testing looks at genes that affect how your body processes certain medications. It usually uses a cheek swab or saliva sample, and the report flags drugs you may break down faster or slower than usual. It does not diagnose disease, and it covers only some medications, so it guides choices rather than deciding them.
Does genetic testing for medications cost money in Canada?
Public health plans in Canada do not cover pharmacogenetic tests, so most people pay out of pocket or use workplace benefits. Prices vary by company and by how many genes are tested. Ask your insurer before you order one, and ask your pharmacist whether the result would actually change your medication choices.
Should I stop medication if my test says it is not a good match?
Do not stop or change a medication on your own because of a test result. Some drugs need to be tapered, and your prescriber has to weigh the result against how the drug is working for you, your other medications, and your health. Book a visit to review the report together instead.
Your next step
If you have been cycling through prescriptions without relief, a pharmacist can review what you take and talk through whether testing could help. The Medimap Health Hub has more on medications and coverage, and you can find a pharmacy near you.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. It does not replace a conversation with a doctor or other qualified health professional who knows your history. If you think you are having a medical emergency, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.
Find an allergy or specialist clinic near you? Search through Medimap — no referral needed.
Search clinics →
