Medimap Logo
A bathroom scale surrounded by vegetables, nuts, a lemon, a yellow measuring tape, and green hand weights

Why BMI Alone Can't Tell Whether Obesity Is Making You Sick

A Nature study finds BMI alone labels many people as unwell who are not. Learn the two proposed stages of obesity and which tests tell them apart.

You step on the scale at the clinic, the nurse does the math, and a single number decides whether your chart says obesity. A major new study argues that the number is labelling many people as unwell who aren't, while telling us very little about who actually needs help.

Only about a quarter to a third of people currently diagnosed with obesity show signs that their weight is already harming their health, according to a study published in the journal Nature on November 11 and reported by Reuters. The research adds weight to calls to stop relying on BMI alone, which is based only on height and weight, and to include body fat and a person's broader health in the diagnosis.

Key takeaways

The study tested a new two-stage approach on more than 844,000 adults in four countries, including China and Spain.

On average, about 27 percent of people with obesity had the clinical stage, compared with about 8.5 percent of all adults.

About 82 percent of people at the pre-clinical stage did not move to the clinical stage during the study.

Canada's 2020 adult obesity guideline already defines obesity by its effect on health, not by BMI alone.

Waist size, blood pressure, blood sugar, cholesterol, and liver tests give a fuller picture than a single number.

Why can't height and weight tell the whole story?

Body mass index divides your weight by your height squared, so height and weight are the only things it sees. It can't tell muscle from fat, and it says nothing about whether extra weight is affecting your heart, liver, joints, or blood sugar.

The study's senior author, Francesco Rubino, chair of metabolic and bariatric surgery at King's College London, told Reuters that doctors have long known BMI is imprecise. Until now, he said, there simply hasn't been a better system to replace it.

How do the pre-clinical and clinical stages differ?

The study tests a proposal made last year by an expert commission and medical organizations, which splits the diagnosis into two clinical stages. Under that approach, a high BMI on its own would no longer mean you have obesity.

People with a high BMI and high body fat would be diagnosed with pre-clinical obesity, a stage that is mainly a risk for future problems. People who also show signs that their organs aren't working as they should would be diagnosed with clinical obesity, which is treated as an active illness that usually needs more urgent care.

Comparison of three ways to label weight, BMI alone, the pre-clinical stage with 82 percent not progressing, and the clinical stage at 27 percent of people with obesity

Which results stood out across four countries?

The researchers applied the criteria to data from more than 844,000 adults in four countries, including China and Spain. On average, only about 27 percent of people with obesity had the clinical stage, which works out to roughly 8.5 percent of all adults.

About 82 percent of people at the pre-clinical stage did not go on to the clinical stage during the study, although progression was higher in China and Spain. The stages also tracked with risk, since people at the clinical stage had a 69 percent higher risk of death, compared with 19 percent for the pre-clinical stage, HealthDay reports. Rubino said in a news release that the pre-clinical stage should be neither treated automatically as active illness nor dismissed as harmless.

Quick poll

Has a health professional ever talked to you about your weight based mainly on your BMI?

What does the Canadian guideline already say?

Canada has been heading this way for a while. The 2020 Canadian guideline on adult obesity, published in CMAJ, defines obesity as excess or abnormal body fat that impairs health, rather than by BMI alone, and asks clinicians to look at the whole person. The new study adds large-scale numbers to that idea.

None of this means weight is irrelevant. Excess body fat can raise the risk of type 2 diabetes, heart problems, and liver and kidney trouble, as our guide to fatty liver and who gets it explains. What the research suggests is that two people with the exact same BMI can be in very different places, so decisions should follow what is happening inside the body.

What should you ask at your next checkup?

If you've been told your BMI is in the obesity range, the most useful step at your next checkup is to ask what else your health care provider is looking at. If those results are healthy, that's worth knowing. If they aren't, you'll have a clearer reason, and a clearer target, for treatment.

Ask for a waist measurement. Our guide to belly fat after 40 explains why fat around the middle says more than total weight.

Check your blood sugar. An A1C or fasting test shows how your body handles sugar, and our guide to finding out about high blood sugar early covers what the results mean.

Know your cholesterol. Use our guide to cholesterol numbers to read your lipid results with your provider.

Ask about blood pressure and liver tests. These show whether extra weight is affecting your organs right now.

Focus on habits you can track. If you're making changes, build meals around enough protein, as our guide to eating enough protein explains, and recheck your numbers over time.

Frequently asked questions

Is BMI still useful at all?

BMI is still a quick screening tool, and a very high BMI does raise the chance of health problems. The new study argues it should start a conversation, not end one. Pairing it with waist size, body fat, and blood tests gives your provider a much clearer idea of whether your weight is affecting your health.

What tests show whether weight is affecting your health?

Common checks include a waist measurement, blood pressure, an A1C or fasting blood sugar test, a cholesterol panel, and liver tests. Your provider may also ask about joint pain, breathing during sleep, and how easily you move. Together, these show whether extra body fat is causing problems now or is mainly a future risk.

Who can help you make sense of your weight and test results?

A family doctor or nurse practitioner can order and explain the tests. A registered dietitian can help you build an eating plan around your results, your budget, and the foods you enjoy. Many workplace benefit plans cover dietitian visits, so it is worth checking your coverage before you book.

Your next step

If you'd like a fuller picture of your health than one number can give you, a dietitian can work with your test results and your everyday routine. The Medimap Health Hub has more on nutrition and weight, and you can find a registered dietitian near you.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. It does not replace a conversation with a doctor or other qualified health professional who knows your history. If you think you are having a medical emergency, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Find an allergy or specialist clinic near you? Search through Medimap — no referral needed.

Search clinics →