Medimap Logo
A doctor in a white coat showing an older patient a set of brain scans on a tablet in her office

Federal Review Finds No Mystery Brain Disease in New Brunswick

A federal review found no mystery brain disease in New Brunswick, yet hundreds of patients still lack answers. See what PHAC found and what happens next.

It started with seizures, confusion, spasms, and tremors. For hundreds of New Brunswickers, those symptoms came with a label that made headlines across the country. A federal review has now delivered its verdict, and almost no one on either side of the story is calling it closure.

The Public Health Agency of Canada says it found no evidence of an unusual pattern of neurological illness among patients linked to the suspected cluster, Global News reports. Its report, published on October 29, lines up with a New Brunswick report from January and a 2025 study in JAMA Neurology, both of which also found no evidence of a mystery brain disease. What it cannot do is explain what is making many of these people sick.

Key takeaways

PHAC reviewed data for 210 patients and found no unusual pattern of neurological illness.

Three separate reviews have now reached the same conclusion since 2022.

PHAC stressed that its finding does not mean patients' symptoms are not real.

It recommended medical follow-up for people still without a diagnosis and better data collection.

If your own symptoms have not been explained, it is reasonable to ask for a reassessment or second opinion.

What did PHAC actually find?

PHAC met with the neurologist who reported the cases, consulted patients and families, examined population health trends, and analyzed data for 210 patients. For the small number who died, death certificates pointed to a range of known neurological and other diagnoses, not one shared condition.

The report is also candid about its limits. According to CTV News, PHAC noted that most patient records lacked the clinical interpretation needed to define a shared diagnosis, which leaves uncertainty about whether something could affect a smaller subgroup. It also could not check for geographic clustering, because identifying details such as addresses had been removed.

Why does the investigation keep coming back?

The concerns date back to 2020, when Dr. Alier Marrero, a neurologist in the province, raised the alarm about patients with unexplained neurological symptoms. The province's first investigation, of 48 patients, found no evidence of a common illness in 2022. In March 2025, New Brunswick's chief medical officer of health, Dr. Yves Léger, announced a review of 222 patient files together with PHAC.

Marrero has suggested that herbicides and metals may be involved, and the number of patients he referred has grown to about 400. Each new review has found no mystery brain disease, yet the patient group keeps growing, which is a big part of why the story refuses to settle. All of the patients in PHAC's review were reported by that single neurologist, which matters for how the data can be read.

Timeline of reviews into unexplained neurological symptoms in New Brunswick from 2020 to the federal report in October 2026
Quick poll

Have you or someone close to you lived with symptoms doctors could not explain?

Where does this leave patients?

PHAC said there is no basis for a new investigation, but it recommended that officials keep communicating with patients, provide medical follow-up for people without a diagnosis, review new diagnoses as they come in, and keep collecting information. Léger said his office has accepted the recommendations and is working with the regional health authorities so patients can get the care they need.

Patients and families have mixed feelings. Sarah Nesbitt of Canaan Station, N.B., who became ill in 2020, told Global News that many patients found the report limited and frustrating, though she is encouraged that PHAC is pushing for better care and data. Caring for people with real symptoms and no answers is a provincial responsibility, as our guide to who decides what in Canadian health care explains.

What can you do about unexplained symptoms?

You do not have to live in New Brunswick to know how exhausting it is to live with unexplained symptoms that nobody can name. Symptoms like these are often dismissed at first, as our guide to symptoms that get brushed off as stress describes, so a few steps help you get taken seriously.

Keep a symptom log. Write down what happens, when, and for how long, so each clinician sees the full picture.

Keep copies of your results. Bring test results and reports to every new appointment instead of relying on records to follow you.

Ask for a reassessment. Diagnoses can change as symptoms evolve, so it is fair to ask for a follow-up assessment, a referral, or a second opinion.

Track specific changes. New numbness, as covered in our guide to numbness and tingling in hands and feet, or memory slips, which our 10-minute memory test can help you describe, are worth noting.

Know the emergencies. Sudden confusion, a first seizure, or new weakness on one side of the body means calling 911.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a mystery brain illness in New Brunswick?

Three separate reviews, from the province, from researchers writing in JAMA Neurology, and now from PHAC, have found no evidence of a mystery brain disease or any other new neurological condition. Many patients turned out to have known conditions. PHAC noted that uncertainty remains for a subgroup without a clear diagnosis, and it recommended continued follow-up.

Does the report mean patients' symptoms are not real?

PHAC said directly that its finding does not mean patients' symptoms or experiences are not real. Many people continue to face serious health problems and are still searching for answers. The report concluded only that the data do not show one shared disease across the group, and it called for ongoing medical follow-up.

What should I do if doctors cannot explain my symptoms?

Keep a detailed log of your symptoms and copies of every test result, and bring both to each appointment. Ask whether a referral, a repeat assessment, or a second opinion makes sense, since diagnoses can change as symptoms evolve. Any sudden confusion, first seizure, or one-sided weakness needs emergency care right away.

Your next step

If you are living with symptoms that still have not been explained, a family doctor can help you start, or restart, that conversation. The Medimap Health Hub has more on getting care in Canada, and you can book a family doctor near you.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. It does not replace a conversation with a doctor or other qualified health professional who knows your history. If you think you are having a medical emergency, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Find an allergy or specialist clinic near you? Search through Medimap — no referral needed.

Search clinics →